Menu Close

The 3 Best Above Ground Pool Heaters You should Consider buying

A quick intro to the best Above Ground Pool Heaters

The temperature of your above-ground pool is crucial to maintain properly. Without the ability to keep your temperature even during the warmer months, the pool will only be truly enjoyable sporadically. Furthermore, the pool will be largely useless, when the colder months start to drift in. Not only do you want to get a heater for your above-ground pool, but you certainly want to be sure you’re also getting one of the best on the market.

We can help. We have put together a list of the 3 best above ground pool heaters available. These come from the top manufacturers in the industry. Each of our choices can appeal to you for different reasons. You will want to make sure any heater you consider will work with your current pool. Nonetheless, if you don’t know where to begin your search, we can help you get started in the best possible direction.

1. GAME 4512 SolarPro XD1 Solar Pool Heater with Adapter for Intex and Bestway above Ground Pools

Not surprisingly, solar pool heaters are all the rage these days. The best examples of solar pool heaters will likely give you what you’re looking for in a heater.

GAME 4512 SolarPro XD1 Solar Pool Heater

They will also offer solid energy savings. If you are interested in such savings, but you don’t want to surround your pool with solar panels, this release should fit the bill. The Game 4512 is an impressive heater, particularly in its price range. The more you learn about the features and benefits of this solar pool heater, the easier it will be to appreciate this for yourself. You will naturally want to make sure your pool is small enough to be properly heated by this product, but that is really the only major consideration. At the end of the day, there are a lot of things to like about this release.


As the name implies, this heater does not use any electricity. There aren’t a lot of built-in features for this product, which emphasizes simplicity above all else. Even the design is straightforward, offering a dome enclosure combined with black tubing. The fact that this heater only measures twenty-three inches may cause you to suspect it won’t be able to do the job. If your pool is 8000 gallons or less, then you should be just fine.


The advantages of this heater can go a long way towards explaining its placement on our list of the 3 best above ground pool heaters on the market. For one thing, this heater is remarkably easy to install. You will have this heater up and running in a matter of minutes. You don’t have to worry about maintenance in the slightest. We also like the design of this heater, which nicely emphasizes consistent water flow. Finally, after the initial investment, you are essentially heating your pool for free.


For some, this heater may be a little on the slow side. If you plan to use your pool for long periods of time daily, then you may want to look elsewhere. Everyone else will love this thing.


This heater currently retails for approximately $94.

Here are some of the top Game 4512 reviews:

  • “This is a surprisingly strong heater!”
  • “I combined this with a solar cover for amazing results.”
  • “Perfect for how often I swim.”

If you meet the size requirements for this heater, and many pools do, you should be pleased with the results.

Check Best Price

2. Hayward H100IDP1 H-Series 100,000 BTU Above Ground Pool & Spa Heater, Propane, Low Nox

Any list of the top above ground pool heaters will have some space for Hayward. For heaters and other essential pool products, Hayward is one of the most respected brands in the world. This above-ground heater is a great example of what they have brought to consumers for a long time. While the price tag is quite a jump from our previous entry, this is nonetheless one of the most powerful options on the market.

hayward H100IDP1 H-Series 100,000 BTU

At the same time, if you are particularly interested in features, the H1001IDP1 is bound to impress you. We love everything about this heater for above ground pools. Even so, make sure this is the right kind of heater for your pool.


Available in a natural gas model or propane model, this is a great heater for anyone who wants absolute control over the temperature of a large above ground swimming pool. Automatic operation occurs with the use of a simple electronic ignition piece. Everything about this heater is simple enough that anyone can use it. The cabinet surface temperature is designed to be cool to your touch. Unique draft technology allows this heater to work under a wide range of circumstances. This pool ultimately works best with pools 450 square feet or smaller.


As we just mentioned, this is a fantastic year-round heater. You may want to also purchase a pool cover, but this heater can quite frankly handle most situations on its own. This heater is capable of 100, 000 BTUs. No, that does not make it the most powerful heater on the market. This is still a product that is going to meet most needs.


There really aren’t any downsides to this heater. Again, the price tag can strike the uninitiated as a bit high. Even so, if you plan to use your pool all through the year, this heater will pay for itself thousand times over.


Currently retails for $1,089.99.

Here are some of the top customer reviews for this second entry on the 3 best above ground pool heaters:

  • “This is a perfect powerhouse for my swimming pool!”
  • Setting this heater up couldn’t have been easier. It’s been working great for the past two years.”
  • “I wish I had found this heater sooner. Really pleased with the results, even when the weather cools.”

This is a strong contender for your wallet, but make sure your pool is the proper size!

Check Best Price

3. Hayward H400FDN Universal H-Series 400,000 BTU Pool and Spa Heater, Natural Gas, Low Nox

Once again, we turn to Hayward for a stellar example of an above ground pool heater. While this is a heater suitable for fairly large above ground pools, there is no question that this is a pool heater for those who are pretty serious about their outdoor setup. If you are looking for a heater with a stellar reputation for offering hydraulic efficiency, this is going to be one of your best choices. The H-Series from Hayward, in general, is a good brand to start with for anyone shopping for one of these products for the first time.

Hayward H400FDN Universal H-Series

Let’s take some of the look at the more compelling features and benefits, as well as the potentially high price tag.


400, 000 BTUs gives this propane or natural gas heater enough power for large pools or spas. For those interested, there are weaker versions ranging from 350, 000 BTUs to 150, 000 BTUs. The polymer header combined with its bypass valve construction emphasizes the hydraulic efficiency we mentioned before. There is a standby mode, which is ideal for anyone who wants to maintain control over their pool temperature at all times.


The standby mode is far and away from our favorite feature with this heater. We love the ability to set the heater up to kick in if the pool reaches a lower-than-desired temperature. Furthermore, we found this feature to be quite reliable. You will also appreciate just how easy it is to install and use this heater. This is also one of the fastest-working heaters we have ever encountered.


The only potential negative can be the price tag, which we will cover shortly. While it does represent an impressive initial investment, it just makes sense to get the best possible heater for a pool or spa in your size range. That would be the larger examples of either on the market.

Price: This heater retails for approximately $2,495.99.

Here are some of the top customer reviews for this release under Hayward’s H-Series:

  • “I live on an island in New Jersey. This heater works no matter what the weather throws at me.”
  • “I needed a powerful heater for my spa. This one has been working out perfectly so far.”
  • “This heater has never failed to meet my spa and swimming pool needs.”

In the end, this is a fantastic heater for larger above ground pools and spas.

Check Best Price

Conclusion on the best above ground pool heater

Among this list of the 3 best above ground pool heaters, you should be able to find exactly what you’re looking for. Whether you want a powerhouse for a larger pool or something reliable and electricity-free for a smaller pool, you should be able to find exactly what you are looking for. This list can go a long way towards giving you a good idea of your options. Keep in mind there are even more possibilities out there to consider. Even so, we would say these are the first three worth a closer look. One of them will likely meet your needs in a spectacular fashion.

Posted in pool heaters

Related Posts